[This proposal was submitted after the deadline. I am announcing it for community discussion and will leave the decision on whether or not to grant an exception to FESCo] https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Changes/GCC9 == Summary == Switch GCC in Fedora 30 to 9.x.y, rebuild all packages with it, or optionally rebuild just some packages with it and rebuild all packages only in Fedora 31. == Owner == * Name: [[User:jakub| Jakub Jelínek]] * Email: jakub(a)redhat.com == Detailed Description == GCC 9 is currently in stage4 since January 7th, in prerelease state with only regression bugfixes and documentation fixes allowed. The release will happen probably in the middle of April. rpms have been built are since today in rawhide. == Benefit to Fedora == See http://gcc.gnu.org/gcc-9/changes.html for the list of changes. == Scope == All packages should be rebuilt with the new gcc once it hits f30, or, if there is not enough time for that, just all packages built after the new gcc hits the buildroots. * Proposal owners: Build gcc in f30, rebuild packages that have direct dependencies on exact gcc version (libtool, annobin, gcc-python-plugin). * Other developers: First few days/weeks just voluntary rebuilds using the new system gcc, if things fail, look at http://gcc.gnu.org/gcc-9/porting_to.html and fix bugs in packages or, if there is a gcc bug or suspected gcc bug, analyze and report. * Release engineering: . Mass rebuild requested for F30. * Policies and guidelines: No policies need to be changed == Upgrade/compatibility impact == No impact == How To Test == GCC has its own testsuite, which is run during the package build, plus many other packages with automated tests also help to test the new gcc. == User Experience == Users will be able to see compiled code improvements and use the newly added features. Developers will notice a newer compiler, and might need to adjust their codebases acording to http://gcc.gnu.org/gcc-9/porting_to.html, or, if they detect a GCC bug, report it. == Dependencies == libtool, annobin, gcc-python-plugin depend on exact gcc version, those need to be rebuilt. == Contingency Plan == If bugs are discovered, I'd appreciate help from the package owners in preparing self-contained testcases to speed up analysis and fixing the bugs. Don't have time to debug issues in 12000+ packages, especially when in many cases it could be caused by undefined code in the packages etc. I don't expect we'll have to fall back to the older gcc, we've never had to do it in the past, but worst case we can mass rebuild everything with older gcc again. Jeff Law has performed test mass rebuild on x86_64. * Contingency mechanism: Revert to older gcc, mass rebuild everything again * Contingency deadline: Before release * Blocks release? Yes * Blocks product? No == Documentation == http://gcc.gnu.org/gcc-9/ == Release Notes == Fedora 30 comes with GCC 9.1 as primary compiler, see http://gcc.gnu.org/gcc-9/changes.html for user visible changes in it. -- Ben Cotton Fedora Program Manager TZ=America/Indiana/Indianapolis