Hello,
Thank you Markus and Aaron for your responses.
--- Markus Huber humarfedoralists@yahoo.de wrote:
Aaron Gaudio schrieb:
On Thu, 2004-08-05 at 21:03 +0100, Rahul Sadotra
wrote:
The only thing that doesn't work is CD playing. I still can't get CD output from the speakers (even though I have put both CD and Audigy CD dials to
full
volume), although I can get CD output through headphones and change volume through headphone
volume
control on my CD-RW and DVD-ROM drives (Which I believe was suggested).
Have you tried using xmms's digital audio
extraction?
Have you checked the analog multimedia cable(s) between the drive(s)
and your soundcard?
Or fitting the cable between CD-Player and motherboard? It sounds stupid, but I was that stupid who forgot that ;-)
I know that all cable connections are correct in my machine because I can get CD music output in Win XP (my PC is dual boot) through speakers whether I use my CD-RW or DVD-ROM drive. Plus, I got CD music through my speakers when I used Red Hat Linux 9 (again, it worked on either drive).
As I already mentioned I upgraded RH 9 to Fedora Core 2. This solved the problem I had of using CD-RWs on my machine on my particular CD-RW drive (it used to take a really long time to mount any CD-RW) that I had - I have no such problems in Fedora Core 2, for CD-RWs can now be mounted very quickly. I think the change in kernel from 2.4.x to 2.6.x helped a lot there.
Unfortunately, CD music in Fedora Core 2 can only be listened to through headphones at the moment. But I'll be okay with that.
Yes, when I use XMMS's CD extraction tool and cdda2wav to create WAV files there is no problem playing music.
Incidentally, my CD-RW drive is a TEAC CD-W524E, and my DVD-ROM drive is a LG DRD-8160B.
I should have mentioned my PC is dual boot in my first post.
Thanks,
Rahul
___________________________________________________________ALL-NEW Yahoo! Messenger - all new features - even more fun! http://uk.messenger.yahoo.com
On or about 2004-08-06 05:08, Rahul Sadotra whipped out a trusty #2 pencil and scribbled:
Hello,
Thank you Markus and Aaron for your responses.
--- Markus Huber humarfedoralists@yahoo.de wrote:
Aaron Gaudio schrieb:
On Thu, 2004-08-05 at 21:03 +0100, Rahul Sadotra
wrote:
The only thing that doesn't work is CD playing. I still can't get CD output from the speakers (even though I have put both CD and Audigy CD dials to
full
volume), although I can get CD output through headphones and change volume through headphone
volume
control on my CD-RW and DVD-ROM drives (Which I believe was suggested).
Have you tried using xmms's digital audio
extraction?
Have you checked the analog multimedia cable(s) between the drive(s)
and your soundcard?
Or fitting the cable between CD-Player and motherboard? It sounds stupid, but I was that stupid who forgot that ;-)
I know that all cable connections are correct in my machine because I can get CD music output in Win XP (my PC is dual boot) through speakers whether I use my CD-RW or DVD-ROM drive. Plus, I got CD music through my speakers when I used Red Hat Linux 9 (again, it worked on either drive).
Just a minor nit-pick here (which also I think is the source of your problems under Linux). It is *NOT* sufficient to say that all your cable connections are correct just because you get CD music output in Windows XP! Windows XP (and 2000 as well) default to the mode where the audio tracks are read *digitally* off of the CD and the resulting data is sent to the sound card just as if you were playing a WAV file.
Linux, on the other hand, defaults to just telling the CD to start playing a certain track, and expects that the *analog* audio that results (like from out of the earphone jack, which you say is playing audio) will be routed from the back of the CD drive into an analog input on the sound card. This is the cable that you probably don't have. It's easy enough to open up your box and see if there is a smallish round audio-type cable coming out of the back of the CD drive and routed to your sound card, or to a connector on the motherboard if your sound hardware is built-in to the motherboard. (One workaround to installing the internal cable is to run a male-to-male stereo cable from the earphone output on the front of the CD around to the back of the box and plug it into the line-in input, *not* the microphone-in input, on your soundboard. )
You could also do a negative check, and in WinXP go into the Device Manager, select the CD drive Properties, and UN-check the box that says "Use digital audio for this device". After that, you should have the same symptoms as you do with Linux, that is, nothing coming out of the speakers, but music available at the earphone jack.
As I already mentioned I upgraded RH 9 to Fedora Core 2. This solved the problem I had of using CD-RWs on my machine on my particular CD-RW drive (it used to take a really long time to mount any CD-RW) that I had
- I have no such problems in Fedora Core 2, for CD-RWs
can now be mounted very quickly. I think the change in kernel from 2.4.x to 2.6.x helped a lot there.
Unfortunately, CD music in Fedora Core 2 can only be listened to through headphones at the moment. But I'll be okay with that.
Yes, when I use XMMS's CD extraction tool and cdda2wav to create WAV files there is no problem playing music.
Incidentally, my CD-RW drive is a TEAC CD-W524E, and my DVD-ROM drive is a LG DRD-8160B.
I should have mentioned my PC is dual boot in my first post.
Thanks,
Rahul
Fritz Whittington wrote:
On or about 2004-08-06 05:08, Rahul Sadotra whipped out a trusty #2 pencil and scribbled:
Hello,
Thank you Markus and Aaron for your responses.
--- Markus Huber humarfedoralists@yahoo.de wrote:
Aaron Gaudio schrieb:
On Thu, 2004-08-05 at 21:03 +0100, Rahul Sadotra
wrote:
The only thing that doesn't work is CD playing. I still can't get CD output from the speakers (even though I have put both CD and Audigy CD dials to
full
volume), although I can get CD output through headphones and change volume through headphone
volume
control on my CD-RW and DVD-ROM drives (Which I believe was suggested).
Have you tried using xmms's digital audio
extraction?
Have you checked the analog multimedia cable(s) between the drive(s)
and your soundcard?
Or fitting the cable between CD-Player and motherboard? It sounds stupid, but I was that stupid who forgot that ;-)
I know that all cable connections are correct in my machine because I can get CD music output in Win XP (my PC is dual boot) through speakers whether I use my CD-RW or DVD-ROM drive. Plus, I got CD music through my speakers when I used Red Hat Linux 9 (again, it worked on either drive).
Just a minor nit-pick here (which also I think is the source of your problems under Linux). It is *NOT* sufficient to say that all your cable connections are correct just because you get CD music output in Windows XP! Windows XP (and 2000 as well) default to the mode where the audio tracks are read *digitally* off of the CD and the resulting data is sent to the sound card just as if you were playing a WAV file. Linux, on the other hand, defaults to just telling the CD to start playing a certain track, and expects that the *analog* audio that results (like from out of the earphone jack, which you say is playing audio) will be routed from the back of the CD drive into an analog input on the sound card. This is the cable that you probably don't have. It's easy enough to open up your box and see if there is a smallish round audio-type cable coming out of the back of the CD drive and routed to your sound card, or to a connector on the motherboard if your sound hardware is built-in to the motherboard. (One workaround to installing the internal cable is to run a male-to-male stereo cable from the earphone output on the front of the CD around to the back of the box and plug it into the line-in input, *not* the microphone-in input, on your soundboard. )
You could also do a negative check, and in WinXP go into the Device Manager, select the CD drive Properties, and UN-check the box that says "Use digital audio for this device". After that, you should have the same symptoms as you do with Linux, that is, nothing coming out of the speakers, but music available at the earphone jack.
As I already mentioned I upgraded RH 9 to Fedora Core 2. This solved the problem I had of using CD-RWs on my machine on my particular CD-RW drive (it used to take a really long time to mount any CD-RW) that I had
- I have no such problems in Fedora Core 2, for CD-RWs
can now be mounted very quickly. I think the change in kernel from 2.4.x to 2.6.x helped a lot there.
Unfortunately, CD music in Fedora Core 2 can only be listened to through headphones at the moment. But I'll be okay with that.
Yes, when I use XMMS's CD extraction tool and cdda2wav to create WAV files there is no problem playing music.
Incidentally, my CD-RW drive is a TEAC CD-W524E, and my DVD-ROM drive is a LG DRD-8160B.
I should have mentioned my PC is dual boot in my first post.
Thanks,
Rahul
No need for the cable, just use xmms and play the audio CD's digitally.
Start xmms choose Preferences (Ctrl+P) select CD Audio Player -> (Input Plugins) -> press the 'Configure' button, ->Play mode: Digital audio extraction
Good Luck,
Dave White
On Fri, 2004-08-06 at 15:13 -0400, David White wrote:
No need for the cable, just use xmms and play the audio CD's digitally.
Start xmms choose Preferences (Ctrl+P) select CD Audio Player -> (Input Plugins) -> press the 'Configure' button, ->Play mode: Digital audio extraction
Though, as I stated earlier, this consumes bandwidth on the IDE bus. Maybe not important in today's UltraDMA/133 world (or even SATA), but it could be a consideration.
On or about 2004-08-06 23:13, Aaron Gaudio whipped out a trusty #2 pencil and scribbled:
On Fri, 2004-08-06 at 15:13 -0400, David White wrote:
No need for the cable, just use xmms and play the audio CD's digitally.
Start xmms choose Preferences (Ctrl+P) select CD Audio Player -> (Input Plugins) -> press the 'Configure' button, ->Play mode: Digital audio extraction
Though, as I stated earlier, this consumes bandwidth on the IDE bus. Maybe not important in today's UltraDMA/133 world (or even SATA), but it could be a consideration.
Also, it puts the volume control for the CD under the influence of the WAV slider, and not the CD slider. You probably want quite different settings for your music versus your system sounds. It also means that the sound drivers must properly share the WAV channel between the CD and the system sounds, and some don't do this very well. The analog mixing is so much simpler.
-
Aaron Gaudio -
David White -
Fritz Whittington -
Rahul Sadotra